Geeks logo

Anatomy of a Murder Exhibits Stark Change in America’s Sociological Perspective

Otto Preminger and its Twist of Fate Stands the Test of Time

By Rich MonettiPublished 7 years ago 3 min read
Like
Columbia Pictures Corporation Poster

Anatomy of a Murder says a lot about how much things have changed in America since it was made in 1959 and makes for a very interesting study in the vast difference in sociological perspective. At the same time, the reluctant charm of Jimmy Stewart holds up as well as ever and still finds no actor today who can carry a movie by simply asserting uncertainty.

The Otto Preminger film finds Lt. Manny Manion, played by Ben Gazzara, in city lockup, having just turned himself in for shooting a local bar owner to death. The inciting incident for Manion is the alleged rape of his young, seductive wife, played by a very young Lee Remick. A lesser charge than murder one is eviscerated of the one hour lapse between Manion learning of the assault and the deadly response to this apparent law abiding citizen.

So the uncertain Stewart, seemingly not knowing what he’s doing as Gazzara’s lawyer, can only go so far, and a coherent defense must be established. Thus Manion leads Stewart to a temporary insanity strategy.

Putting the Victim on Trial

This obviously brings the rape back into play and herein lays a stark disparity to the world we live in today.

Our introduction to Laura Manion reveals a carefree, flirty young girl who sports her black eye as easily as the flow of her alluring red hair. The manner in which Remick offhandedly exposes the details of her abduction and violent assault are perplexing, to say the least.

Distinctively absent are the harrowing accounts we know from Law and Order or even the nightly news. Conversely, Remick’s presentation of the facts makes the incident seem like an inconvenience.

Interestingly, this didn’t lead me to question the insensitivity of the filmmakers. Instead, it felt more like society of 1950s America possessed a sheer lack of knowledge in regards to the devastating impacts of a sexual assault. This particularly comes from males who proceed in making vastly uninformed assumptions.

That said, consideration to the victim and putting her on trial in cross-examination was still decades away. In fact, George C. Scott, as the prosecuting attorney, gets right up in Remick’s grill. Demanding clarifications to the point of tears, he impinges Remick’s flirtatious behavior with the perpetrator on the pertinent evening, while calling into serious question the overall fidelity of the young bride.

Legally Jockeying and a Twist of Fate

Putting aside the deficiencies in sociological perspective, the chances of Stewart obtaining an acquittal hinge on the admissibility of the actual rape. In this, he’s also up against the aforementioned gap and the prosecution’s intent on suppressing Remick’s testimony. The legal jockeying does, though, provide great entertainment value for the viewer. Front and center, Joseph N. Welch refereeing the back and forth between Stewart and Scott as sitting Judge Weaver gives Anatomy of a Murder a definite place among movie classics.

Somewhat passive aggressively, with his small town demeanor and a touch of grandfatherly wisdom, Welch steers the two attorneys to acceptable middle grounds without seriously hurting the feelings of either petulant child/lawyer. In turn, the verdict lies in whether temporary insanity holds up in the face of a defendant who’s clearly hot headed with a violent history of jealous behavior.

As such, an insanity defense on film might be close to a first for Hollywood. On the other hand, if you really want to see this type of scenario play out, take a look at Primal Fear with Richard Gere and Ed Norton. But the irony in which the revelation is delivered definitely stands the test of time and makes this particular anatomy worth your time. The same goes for its place as a sociological measuring stick.

Rich Monetti can be reached at [email protected]

moviepop culturereview
Like

About the Creator

Rich Monetti

I am, I write.

Reader insights

Be the first to share your insights about this piece.

How does it work?

Add your insights

Comments

There are no comments for this story

Be the first to respond and start the conversation.

Sign in to comment

    Find us on social media

    Miscellaneous links

    • Explore
    • Contact
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms of Use
    • Support

    © 2024 Creatd, Inc. All Rights Reserved.